For the price I paid, this was a great stay. A waterfront room in Mackinac for under $100 is wild! Everything was dated but comfortable, so while it doesn’t have the greatest look in the world, I slept very well in my room with the sound of the waves outside. Free hot breakfast was better than most. Staff was extremely kind and courteous with me, though I did overhear some terse conversations with others, so I can understand the shaky reviews in service. Overall, I would probably be fairly unhappy if I’d paid $200 for this room, but for what I paid, I’m ecstatic with my stay. I should add that I was a woman traveling alone and felt perfectly safe in the space as well.