Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Embrace the Enchantment of Shelter Island Heights: Where Nature Meets Coastal Charm

Escape to Shelter Island Heights, a serene seaside getaway on the charming Shelter Island. With its picturesque beaches, lush landscapes, and cozy accommodations, this enchanting destination is perfect for romance and relaxation. Stroll along Sunset Beach, where golden sunsets paint the sky, or explore the island's tranquil nature trails. Delight in the vibrant local culture and indulge in exquisite dining options. Whether you seek adventure or a peaceful retreat, Shelter Island Heights offers an idyllic blend of island vibes and natural beauty, making it a hidden gem for travelers yearning for a unique experience.

Discover great hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights offers a variety of hotel accommodations, ranging from cozy country inns to charming boutique hotels. Visitors can find luxury options with stunning views, comfortable guest rooms, and budget-friendly stays, making it an ideal destination for a relaxing getaway. These are some of the hotels preferred by our travelers in Shelter Island Heights:

1. Harbor Knoll Bed & BreakfastOpens in a new window: Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast is a charming 3.0-star Bed and Breakfast that caters to leisure travelers seeking a beach and golf-themed vacation experience. This property boasts direct access to the beach, allowing guests to enjoy sun-soaked days by the water. The golf experience is a standout feature, with opportunities for enthusiasts to participate in themed activities. Review sentiments highlight the welcoming atmosphere, comfortable accommodations, and the perfect blend of relaxation and recreation, making it an ideal spot for those looking to unwind and indulge in their favorite sports.
2. The Harbor Front InnOpens in a new window: The Harbor Front Inn is a 3.5-star hotel that perfectly suits business travelers seeking a pet-friendly environment. This property stands out with its dedicated services and facilities designed to cater to the needs of business guests, ensuring a seamless and productive stay. The hotel allows some pets onsite, providing a comfortable experience for travelers who wish to bring their furry companions. Positive reviews emphasize the hotel's thoughtful amenities, including express check-in and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a top choice for professionals looking to blend work and leisure.
3. The MenhadenOpens in a new window: The Menhaden is a 3.5-star hotel that attracts adventure seekers looking for a pet-friendly getaway. With a range of adventure sports and recreation activities available onsite and nearby, including hiking, biking, sailing, and kayaking, this property offers an exhilarating escape into nature. The vibrant atmosphere and engaging experiences are complemented by a welcoming pet policy for those who travel with their dogs. Guests rave about the exciting activities available and the comfortable accommodations that make for an unforgettable adventure-filled stay.

Top locations to stay in Shelter Island Heights

Some of the best areas to stay in when visiting Shelter Island Heights are Greenport, Sag Harbor, and Noyack. Greenport offers nature and beautiful beaches, making it perfect for a seaside getaway. Sag Harbor, with its charming port and boating culture, provides a vibrant atmosphere. Noyack is ideal for sailing enthusiasts. For first-time visitors, Sag Harbor is the best choice, blending charm and activities seamlessly.

1. GreenportOpens in a new window: Greenport is a charming maritime village that’s perfect for those who appreciate nature and waterfront beauty. Known for its picturesque harbor, visitors can enjoy scenic walks along the waterfront and explore local parks. The area is rich in outdoor activities, including kayaking and birdwatching, making it an ideal spot for nature lovers. Greenport's vibrant arts scene features local galleries and cultural events, ensuring there's always something to see and do. Plus, the town's historic charm adds to its appeal, with quaint shops and inviting cafes lining the streets.
2. Sag HarborOpens in a new window: Sag Harbor is a delightful blend of history and coastal charm, offering a unique experience for travelers. Its rich maritime history is showcased in the quaint architecture and cultural attractions throughout the area. Visitors can enjoy leisurely strolls along the picturesque streets, filled with boutique shops and art galleries. The waterfront provides ample opportunities for boating and enjoying the beautiful bay views. With a variety of local events and cultural happenings, Sag Harbor is a lively destination that captures the essence of the Hamptons.
3. NoyackOpens in a new window: Noyack offers a tranquil escape with a focus on sailing and its serene port setting. This small community is ideal for those looking to unwind and soak in the coastal atmosphere. Visitors can indulge in outdoor activities such as sailing and fishing, taking advantage of the area’s beautiful waterways. The close-knit feel of Noyack allows for a peaceful retreat, making it a great spot for relaxation while still being near the attractions of the larger nearby towns. The natural surroundings and laid-back vibe make Noyack a hidden gem for travelers seeking a quieter experience.

Things to do in Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights invites travelers to explore its stunning beaches and lush forests, perfect for hiking and camping. Enjoy sunset views over the water, indulge in boating or sea diving, and experience live performances under the stars. With opportunities for golf and whale watching, this island oasis promises unforgettable memories.

• Harbes Family FarmOpens in a new window – Dive into the charm of rural life at Harbes Family Farm, where you can pick fresh fruits, enjoy seasonal activities, and engage with farm animals. This family-friendly destination is perfect for a day out, featuring delicious homemade treats and fun events throughout the year.
• Orient Point County ParkOpens in a new window – Spend a day in nature at Orient Point County Park, where you can explore scenic trails, picnic by the water, and take in stunning views of the Long Island Sound. This urban park offers a blend of relaxation and outdoor adventure, ideal for families and solo explorers alike.
• 67 Steps BeachOpens in a new window – Relax at 67 Steps Beach, a cozy spot perfect for sunbathing and beachcombing. The picturesque setting invites you to unwind by the shore, making it a great place to enjoy the sound of waves and feel the warm sand between your toes.
• Sag Harbor Marine ParkOpens in a new window – Head to Sag Harbor Marine Park for a day of waterfront activities. With its marina, you can rent boats, go fishing, or simply enjoy the vibrant atmosphere of the harbor. It's an excellent spot to soak up the sun and watch the boats go by.

5 tips for savvy savings when booking a hotel in Shelter Island Heights

1. Book for the cheapest times: The most budget-friendly time to visit Shelter Island Heights is from January to March, when hotel prices tend to be lower. For an affordable getaway, a stay of at least 2 to 3 days is recommended to fully explore the area's key landmarks, historical sites, and cultural attractions. During your visit, you can enjoy activities such as whalewatching, golf, and theater performances, as well as relaxing at the beach or camping. This timeframe offers great value for money while allowing you to appreciate the unique charm of Shelter Island Heights.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: To discover last-minute deals to Shelter Island Heights, visit the DealsOpens in a new window or Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window section on Hotels.com, where you may find discounted rates on nearby hotels as your travel date approaches. Enabling email alerts or push notifications will help you stay informed about flash sales and special promotions, so you could save on your stay. Additionally, the Smart ShoppingOpens in a new window tool available through the app allows you to compare hotel prices and amenities, ensuring you're more likely to see the best options. You'll be among the first to know about any price drops or availability changes for your favorite hotels.
3. Be flexible with dates: Prices can fluctuate based on various factors like the hotel's location, star rating, and the time of year, so being flexible with your travel dates may help you save on your stay at a Shelter Island Heights hotel. If you’re in search of something different, boutique hotels often provide a more personalized experience and could offer better value. When you book through Hotels.com, we’ll inform you whether the price for your chosen dates is above or below the average. If the price is on the higher side, we’ll recommend alternative dates that might be more budget-friendly, increasing the chances that you'll find a great deal.
4. Consider your location: Staying near major attractions or downtown areas can be convenient, but it often comes with a higher price tag. If you’re looking for more budget-friendly options, consider hotels in neighborhoods that are usually more affordable while still offering reasonable access to your desired destinations. You might also check out independent hotels a bit further away, as they can provide a more authentic experience at a lower cost.
5. Become a Member: Join our membership for free and unlock amazing savings on your next stay in Shelter Island Heights! Enjoy exclusive member prices on over 100,000 hotels worldwide. As a member, you can easily move up through our tiers to access incredible perks, including complimentary room upgrades (when available) and discounts on food and beverages at select VIP Access properties. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to enhance your travel experience—become a member today!

Best time to go to Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights experiences its lowest average temperature in January, at 35.6°F (2.0°C), while August is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 73.4°F (23.0°C). October are typically the wettest months. If you’re looking to soak up the lively atmosphere in Shelter Island Heights, April, June, and July are the peak months to visit, bustling with fellow travelers. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, with light rainfall. However, if you prefer a more relaxed experience, January, November, and December are perfect for a quieter getaway, marked by light rainfall and mostly sunny to mostly cloudy conditions.