There was a lot to like at this hotel -- the room itself was very nice and we liked the style of the renovation, both in the guest rooms and with respect to the pool area and lobby/restaurant/bar building. The staff at the desk and in the restaurant area were also great and helpful, and the breakfast was solid. We found the location excellent as well, both for walking into town and for driving to some hiking areas around the city. The main negative for us was that the sound proofing between rooms is not very good, so we had several nights of very poor / interrupted sleep due to loud (or just not fastidiously quiet late at night) neighbors. It was also strange that, although we were out of the room for at least 6-7 hours continuously each day, we only had our room serviced by housekeeping once in our 6 day stay. An investment in more soundproofing, especially with respect to the doors connecting rooms, and maybe a tweak to the system that the housekeeping staff is using to check for when guests are out for the day would make this a 5 star place to stay, easily. I recommend it as long as you bring earplugs and/or a white noise machine to help ensure a good night's sleep, and don't mind asking for towels when you need them and taking out your own trash! On balance, we did enjoy our stay and had a good visit to Tucson.