4 Star Hotels in Siesta Key
Check prices for these dates
4 Star Hotels in Siesta Key
Popular Siesta Key 4-star hotels to try out

Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound
Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound
Top neighborhoods in Siesta Key

Siesta Key Village
Siesta Key Village feels like a tropical daydream with tiki bars and surf shops surrounding America's top-rated beach. You'll find sugar-white sand just steps from colorful boutiques, while live music drifts through palm-lined streets. Sunset cocktails flow as freely as the Gulf breeze at open-air restaurants where fresh grouper sandwiches are practically required eating. Getting around is easy on foot within the compact village core, though many visitors rent golf carts for style points. Vacation rentals and boutique hotels dominate the accommodation scene, most offering beach gear and those essential sunset views. When night falls, the village lights up with beachfront dining and steel drum soundtracks.

Bay Island
Bay Island offers an exclusive slice of paradise on Siesta Key with direct access to award-winning beaches and stunning Gulf views. This peaceful residential enclave features luxury waterfront properties with private docks, perfect for beach lovers and boating enthusiasts. You'll be just minutes from the powdery white sands that made Siesta Key famous and close to Shell Beach and Lido Beach. Dining requires a short drive to nearby Siesta Key Village or Sarasota for fresh seafood and upscale restaurants. Accommodation options focus on high-end vacation rentals with premium amenities like private pools. A rental car is essential for exploring the area's attractions, including Marie Selby Botanical Gardens and St. Armands Circle.
Aloha Kai
Aloha Kai delivers pristine beach access without the tourist crowds of busier Siesta Key spots. The neighborhood sits between sugar-white Siesta Key Beach and tranquil intracoastal waters, giving you the best of both worlds. Crystal-clear Gulf waters invite swimming year-round, while the neighborhood's peaceful streets and tropical landscaping create a true vacation vibe. Most accommodations offer luxury vacation rentals with private pools and Gulf views. You'll find limited dining within the neighborhood, but Siesta Key Village is just a 10-minute drive away. The flat terrain makes for easy walking and biking, while rental cars are recommended for exploring beyond this peaceful beachfront haven.

Bay Isle
Bay Isle delivers pristine Gulf beaches with powder-soft sand that squeaks beneath your feet. This exclusive Siesta Key neighborhood offers direct access to turquoise waters, upscale waterfront dining, and scenic walking paths along both Gulf and bay shores. Shell Beach stands as the crown jewel, where sugar-white sands meet crystal-clear waters perfect for swimming and snorkeling. The area features predominantly luxury vacation rentals and high-end condominiums with stunning water views. Getting around is easy with golf carts popular for local travel, while rental cars are recommended for exploring beyond this peaceful coastal haven. Limited nightlife creates a sophisticated evening atmosphere centered around sunset cocktails and upscale dining.
Top landmarks in Siesta Key

Siesta Key Beach
If being by the water is a major draw, Siesta Key Beach is one of the most popular seaside spots located 0.9 mi (1.5 km) from central Siesta Key. Enjoy the sunset by the shore at Lido Beach, Crescent Beach, and Turtle Beach.

Crescent Beach
If you can't wait to get to the beach, you might enjoy a trip to Crescent Beach located 2.3 mi (3.8 km) from central Siesta Key. Enjoy the sunset by the shore at Siesta Key Beach, Lido Beach, and Turtle Beach.
Find out more about 4 Star Hotels in Siesta Key
Find out more about 4 Star Hotels in Siesta Key
How affordable are 4-star hotels in Siesta Key compared to 5-star options?
How affordable 4-star hotels in Siesta Key are compared to 5-star options depends on several factors, such as property location. A 4-star hotel in Siesta Key's most sought-after areas will typically cost more than a 5-star hotel that's a little further away from the main attractions. Luckily, you can quickly compare prices for 5-star and 4-star hotels in Siesta Key with Hotels.com's easy-to-use search wizard. Enter your dates and destination, check the 4- and 5-star filters, and hit the search button. It'll then throw up real-time prices so you can get a feel for how they compare.
What services are typically offered at 4-star hotels in Siesta Key?
Four-star hotels in Siesta Key usually offer all the services you need for a comfortable stay, such as concierges, valet parking, and laundry facilities. Most 4-star properties also have at least one on-site restaurant serving delicious breakfasts, lunches, and dinners. You'll typically find an on-site bar and café, too. If it's R&R you're seeking, you'll be pleased to know that many upper mid-range hotels in Siesta Key boast fitness centers, pools, and even spas with massages and treatments. Some even offer kid-friendly services, such as children's play areas and kids' clubs. Remember to use the search filters on Hotels.com if you need specific amenities or services.
Do Siesta Key 4-star hotels offer flexible booking and free cancellation?
Yes, many 4-star hotels in Siesta Key offer free cancellation when booked on Hotels.com, meaning you'll get a full refund if you change your mind. Be sure to double-check the booking policies before paying for your stay, as each property has different cancellation rules. Some may even have refundable and non-refundable rates for the same room. Luckily, all this information is crystal clear on Hotels.com. The “free cancellation” label indicates flexible booking, while the “fully refundable” search filter lets you instantly view the most flexible four-star hotels in Siesta Key. If your plans change after booking, you can cancel your booking by logging into “Trips” and following the easy steps.
What are some highly rated 4-star hotels near Siesta Key's city center?
Thanks to Hotels.com's handy search map, you can easily view some of the top-rated 4-star hotels near Siesta Key's center. It not only shows you where each hotel is, but the pop-up also reveals the guest ratings based on countless reviews from fellow travelers. The “Exceptional,” “Wonderful,” and “Very good” ratings each indicate a score of 8 out of 10 or higher based on guest ratings. Click on the hotel page to read the comments, too. All reviews on Hotels.com are real, unfiltered, and unbiased, so you can trust the ratings you see. As well as the map, the “property location” and “guest rating” filters also let you view the top-rated four-star hotels near Siesta Key's different areas.
What types of rooms and suites are available in 4-star hotels in Siesta Key?
You'll find that most 4-star hotels in Siesta Key offer a wide range of different room types. If you're seeking somewhere a little more spacious, you'll be pleased to know that the majority of upper-mid-range properties offer spacious suites with more room to stretch out. For a comfortable space for you and your kids, keep an eye out for family rooms, too. To view what rooms and suites each hotel has, click on its dedicated page, where you'll find a run-down of room types with an easy-to-read description. You'll see the size, inclusions, and cancellation policy.
Are there budget-friendly 4-star hotels near Siesta Key with good reviews?
If you're seeking an affordable getaway, you'll find many well-rated cheap 4-star hotels in Siesta Key. You can find these in a few easy clicks with Hotels.com's search filters, too. Use a combination of the “4-star rating” filter, the “Wonderful” or “Very good” guest rating filters, and the “max price” toggle bar to view top-rated four-star hotels in Siesta Key within your budget. You can even enter the maximum amount you want to pay for your Siesta Key 4-star hotel. Remember, One KeyOpens in a new window members unlock instant savings on thousands of hotels simply by signing in when searching for hotels. You can also access special discounts by searching and booking through the Hotels.com app.
Are 4 star hotels in Siesta Key suitable for business travelers?
The “Business friendly” traveler experience filter will reveal some of the best 4-star hotels in Siesta Key for work. These properties typically boast everything you could need for a productive stay, including conference facilities, dedicated workspaces, and high-speed internet.
What amenities do 4-star hotels in Siesta Key provide?
The amenities at four-star hotels in Siesta Key usually include at least one on-site restaurant and bar, as well as a pool, fitness center, and even a spa. In many cases, you'll find family amenities, like a play area and even a kids' club. Remember, the search filters on Hotels.com let you pin down upper-mid-range hotels with the specific amenities you need. The detailed and up-to-date hotel descriptions on Hotels.com show what amenities you'll find at specific properties.
Keep exploring
Keep exploring
- Hotels with a Pool Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Hotels with Parking Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Hotels with a Fitness Center Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Hotels with Kitchens Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Villas in Crescent Beach
- Apartments in Crescent Beach
- Cheap Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Luxury Hotels near Crescent Beach
- 2 Star Hotels in Crescent Beach
- 3 Star Hotels in Crescent Beach
- 4 Star Hotels in Crescent Beach
- Beach Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Golf Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Hotels near Crescent Beach
- Hotels near Coolidge Park
- Hotels near The Landings
- Hotels near Bee Ridge Park
- Hotels near Gulf Gate Mall
- Hotels near Irma Beach
- Hotels near Shell Beach
- Bay Island Hotels
- Tampa Hotels
- Orlando Hotels
- St. Petersburg Hotels
- Clearwater Beach Hotels
- St. Pete Beach Hotels
- Bradenton Hotels
- Venice Hotels
- Hotels near Walt Disney World® Resort
- Hotels with Kitchens in Sarasota
- Pet Friendly Hotels in Sarasota
- Cheap Hotels in Sarasota
- Luxury Hotels in Sarasota
- 2 Star Hotels in Sarasota
- 3 Star Hotels in Sarasota
- 4 Star Hotels in Sarasota
- Beach Hotels in Sarasota
- Sarasota Hotels
- Hotels near Marie Selby Botanical Gardens
- Hotels near Mote Marine Laboratory & Aquarium
- Hotels near Siesta Key Beach
- Hotels near South Lido Park
- Hotels near St. Armands Circle
- Hotels near Lido Beach
- Hotels near Sarasota Memorial Hospital
- Hotels near Coconuts Family Entertainment Center
- Hotels near Gulf Gate Golf Club
- Hotels near Point of Rocks
- Hotels near St. Boniface Episcopal Church Labyrinth
- Hotels near Siesta Key Marina
- Hotels near Sarasota Memorial Health Care System
- Ridge Wood Heights Hotels
- Hotels with Parking in Gulf Gate Estates
- 3 Star Hotels in Gulf Gate Estates
- Gulf Gate Estates Hotels
- Resorts & Hotels with Spas in Saint Armands Key
- Saint Armands Key Hotels
- Long Meadow Hotels
- Arlington Park Hotels
- Bungalow Hill Hotels
- Bay Isle Hotels
- Cherokee Park Hotels
- Flora Villa Hotels
- Paradise Shores Hotels
- Aloha Kai Hotels
- Oyster Bay Hotels
- Bird Key Hotels
- Harbor Acres Hotels
- Downtown Sarasota Hotels
- Granada Hotels
- Riverview Estates Hotels
- Hudson Bayou Hotels
- Ringling Estates Hotels
- South Sarasota Hotels
- Lido Shores Hotels
- Bayview Hotels
- Shoreland Woods Hotels
- South Poinsettia Hotels
- San Remo Hotels
- Avondale Hotels
- Coral Cove Hotels
- Hotels with a Pool in Siesta Key Village
- Hotels with Parking in Siesta Key Village
- Hotels with Kitchens in Siesta Key Village
- Pet Friendly Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- Apartments in Siesta Key Village
- Cheap Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- Luxury Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- 2 Star Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- 3 Star Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- 4 Star Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- Beach Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- Golf Hotels in Siesta Key Village
- Siesta Key Village Hotels
- Anna Maria Island Hotels