Hotels in Hay Beach

Free cancellation options if plans change
Unlock travel rewards with One Key
Save more with Member Prices

Check prices for these dates

Tonight
Aug 18 - Aug 19
Tomorrow
Aug 19 - Aug 20
This weekend
Aug 22 - Aug 24
Next weekend
Aug 29 - Aug 31

Where to stay in Hay Beach?

American Beech Hotel
Exterior

American Beech Hotel

3.5 star property
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (189)
$294 nightly
The price is $336
Aug 25 - Aug 26
Total includes taxes and fees
American Beech Hotel
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Top landmarks in Shelter Island

Gardiner's Bay Country Club

You might want to play some rounds at Gardiner's Bay Country Club, located 1.8 mi (2.9 km) from central Shelter Island. If Gardiner's Bay Country Club doesn't quite scratch your golfing itch, Shelter Island Country Club, and Island's End Golf and Country Club are also nearby.

See properties in Gardiner's Bay Country Club
Gardiner's Bay Country Club

Check out reviews of Hay Beach hotels guests love

Greenporter Hotel

Greenporter Hotel

10/10 Excellent
"Great place!"
Jake 1-night trip
Posted 1 day ago
Greenporter Hotel

Frequently asked questions

Is Hay Beach expensive to stay in?
You can find great hotels from $94 in Hay Beach to suit a range of budgets. To find the best low-cost hotel on Hotels.com that meets your needs, apply your search filters and then sort hotels by "Price: low to high".
How can I find discounted rates and deals for Hay Beach hotels?
Discover great deals on hotels in Hay Beach with Hotels.com. Sign up for free to unlock member only prices and start earning rewards. It's also a good idea to look at hotel prices mid-week or during the low season as you're likely to find off-peak deals. If you're up for a spontaneous trip, don't forget to check out our last-minute deals on Hay Beach hotels.
How can I find discounted rates and deals for Hay Beach hotels?
Unlocking discounted rates at hotels in Hay Beach couldn't be simpler. Members save up to 20% on select hotels when signed in. Silver, Gold, and Platinum members can earn additional rewards on VIP Access bookings.
Can I receive a refund if I cancel my Hay Beach hotel booking?
The majority of hotels offer free cancellation, so you can receive a refund if you need to cancel your booking. Some Hay Beach hotels require you to cancel more than 24 hours before check-in, so look at your booking beforehand. For extra peace of mind before you book, filter hotels by "Property cancellation options" and select "Fully refundable property".
What are some of the best pet-friendly hotels in Hay Beach?
Traveling with your pet doesn't mean sacrificing a great hotel stay. In Hay Beach, our travelers love:To find more pet-friendly stays on Hotels.com, use the "Amenities" filter in your search and select "Pet friendly".
Is it worth staying in Hay Beach?
There are 10 hotels in the area to find your perfect somewhere. Basing yourself in Hay Beach makes it easy to explore Shelter Island Heights, including the neighborhoods of Pipes Cove and The Heights.
Are all taxes and fees included in the Hay Beach hotel prices shown on Hotels.com?
Hotels.com provides upfront pricing so you can relax knowing you won't be met with surprise additional fees or taxes when you're ready to confirm your booking. From the time you start your search on Hotels.com, the price you see is what you pay. This makes it much easier to compare properties and secure our best deal for your next getaway.
What are some of the best Hay Beach hotels with a pool?
Book a Hay Beach hotel with a pool for some added relaxation or exercise on your trip. For more Hay Beach hotels with a pool, use the "Amenities" filter in your search and select "Pool" on Hotels.com.
Is it worth staying in Hay Beach?
There are 10 hotels in the area to find your perfect somewhere. Basing yourself in Hay Beach makes it easy to explore Shelter Island Heights, including the neighborhoods of Pipes Cove and Silver Beach.
What are some great hotels in Hay Beach with balconies?
There are some top hotels in Hay Beach that offer rooms with a balcony.
Are all taxes and fees included in the Hay Beach hotel prices shown on Hotels.com?
Hotels.com provides upfront pricing so you can relax knowing you won't be met with surprise additional fees or taxes when you're ready to confirm your booking. From the time you start your search on Hotels.com, the price you see is what you pay. This makes it much easier to compare properties and secure our best deal for your next getaway.

Find out more about Hay Beach

Find out more about Hay Beach

What's Hay Beach Like?

If you're in search of the perfect area to explore, why not check out Hay Beach? Take time to see the sights like Menhadden Lane Beach while you're here. Greenport Carousel and Railroad Museum of Long Island are two places to visit nearby.

Where are the Best Places to Stay in Hay Beach?

We have 12 accommodations in the neighborhood. Our travelers don't have any top picks in Hay Beach but here are some of their favorites nearby:

    Sound View Greenport - 3.5 mi (5.6 km) away

    Beachfront hotel with 2 bars, restaurant
    • Free breakfast • Free WiFi • Outdoor pool • Beach sun loungers • Attentive staff

    The Harbor Front Inn - 1.7 mi (2.7 km) away

    Bayfront hotel with 24-hour health club, 24-hour fitness center
    • Free breakfast • Free WiFi • Outdoor pool • Beach sun loungers • Central location

    The Shoals Suites and Slips - 4.1 mi (6.7 km) away

    Bayfront hotel with restaurant, bar
    • Free breakfast • Free in-room WiFi • Cafe • Attentive staff

How to Get to Hay Beach

Flying to:

  • East Hampton, NY (HTO), 10.5 mi (16.9 km) from Hay Beach
  • Fishers Island, NY (FID-Elizabeth Field), 18.9 mi (30.5 km) from Hay Beach
  • Montauk, NY (MTP), 21.2 mi (34.1 km) from Hay Beach

Things to See and Do in and around Hay Beach

Things to See near Hay Beach:

  • Menhadden Lane Beach (0.8 mi/1.3 km away)
  • Greenport Carousel (1.6 mi/2.6 km away)
  • 67 Steps Beach (2.5 mi/4.1 km away)
  • Sunset Beach (2.6 mi/4.1 km away)
  • Crescent Beach (2.9 mi/4.6 km away)

Things to Do near Hay Beach:

  • Railroad Museum of Long Island (1.8 mi/2.9 km away)
  • Kontokosta Winery (2.1 mi/3.4 km away)
  • Gardiner's Bay Country Club (0.5 mi/0.8 km away)
  • Shelter Island Whale's Tail (1.6 mi/2.6 km away)
  • Greenport Farmers' Market (1.7 mi/2.7 km away)

When Is the Best Time to Visit Shelter Island?